Leak in the system
County officials dismiss tunnel's water problem at Justice Center site
Timeline of Routt County Justice Center
Routt County voters reject a mill levy to fund a $17.2 million justice center and parking garage in downtown Steamboat Springs. County commissioners spent $2.2 million on land purchases and architectural designs for the downtown site.
Judge Richard Doucette orders county officials to construct a new justice center by Sept. 1, 2006. The Colorado Court of Appeals later overturned the order.
County commissioners host public meetings to discuss justice center locations. Two years of public debate ensue. The Steamboat Springs City Council and a community group named Friends of the Justice Center - led by current councilman Towny Anderson - support a new justice center downtown. Commissioners support a site west of town, adjacent to the Routt County Jail.
The U.S. Army Corp of Engineers issues a preliminary decision denying the county's application for the construction of a new justice center on 1.4 acres of wetlands at the site west of downtown, saying a downtown site would cause less environmental damage.
Commissioners prepare three further studies about the wetlands site, at an estimated cost of $15,000, for the Corps of Engineers.
Col. Ronald Light, Corps district engineer, makes a final decision on the permit, authorizing construction at the wetlands site. Light cites room for expansion, proximity to the jail, possible flooding from the Butcherknife Creek downtown and a lower cost as reasons for approving the site. The 52,000-square-foot facility is estimated to cost $15 million, to be paid from existing and future tax revenues. The new center will not go before voters.
U.S. District Court Judge Robert E. Blackburn dismisses a lawsuit filed by Towny Anderson, challenging the Army Corps' wetlands permit approval. Blackburn cites the lawsuit's failure to "prove the existence of a justifiable case or controversy."
Commissioners select FCI Constructors, which has Colorado offices in Grand Junction, Durango and Longmont, as contractor for the new justice center construction. FCI submitted a bid of $13,354,700.
Excavation and construction work begins at the site west of downtown.
- Compiled by Mike Lawrence
Steamboat Springs — Water trickles steadily into an underground tunnel being built as part of the new Routt Court Justice Center west of town.
The water collects and pools in the tunnel, which is supposed to connect the Justice Center with the Routt County Jail.
On Friday, county officials said the water seeping into the supposed waterproof tunnel is a minor setback and is being handled appropriately.
“We are experiencing some seepage issues right now,” said Tim Winter, the county’s building and plant director. “There is some water down there right now but the contractor’s intent is to inject a hydro-type material that they’re confident will seal off any leak.”
Pumps are being used to remove water from the tunnel area.
Paul Barry, construction manager, said he did not know how much water has been pumped out of the tunnel because the pumps are not running constantly.
“Because it’s out of sight and no one can see it, everyone thinks there’s got to be something going on,” he said. “It isn’t like that. It’s a tunnel with a leak.”
Ultimately, the general contractor building the $13.4 million Justice Center will be responsible for containing the leaks and ensuring the secure tunnel is waterproof.
“By the time we open this to the public,” Barry said, “no one will even know there was a water issue or that it’s a tunnel completely submerged in water.”
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers had to approve construction and mitigation plans for the Justice Center site because it is in a wetlands area. That approval came in 2005.
Construction planners knew the water was going to be an issue.
As of September 2006, nearly 8.5 million gallons of water had been pumped from the underground tunnel site, after crews tapped into a large amount of underground water.
The tunnel was installed in July and August 2006 in pre-cast chunks of concrete. The 200-foot secure tunnel is designed for transporting inmates.
The tunnel is in the middle of the wetland and alluvial area. The tunnel is surrounded by perforated piping encased in gravel to allow the water to flow above and below the waterproof tunnel.
It will perform
County Manager Tom Sullivan said as with any construction project, issues arise once a product is installed in a real environment.
“What we have is an engineered product that needs to be applied to actual conditions,” he said. “It’s a minor problem with the installation and the condition of the environment. What we’re using is a proven material that has been used before and performed well. Our expectation is that it will perform well.”
Barry said the cost of mitigating the tunnel seepage is the responsibility of the contractor and sub-contractors, not the county.
Winter said the tunnel will not have ongoing water issues, and that pumps that have been installed in the tunnel are there only for emergency situations, not as a permanent solution.
“The bottom line is that they have to give us a waterproof tunnel,” Winter said. “They have to do that whether they fix it with the sealant or they tear it up and do it again.”
Anderson predicted problem
Steamboat Springs City Council member Towny Anderson led Friends of the Justice Center, a group that advocated building the Justice Center downtown. The group argued that a wetlands permit should not be issued for the west-of-town site.
Anderson has predicted for months that water in the tunnel would be a major problem.
“This is a groundwater, recharge area and an obvious source of water for the wetlands,” he said. “Clearly it is a far greater volume of water, and a constant source of water, than the county had counted on.”
Anderson questions the research that went into approving the site as a feasible construction site.
“To characterize this as a minimal problem is a concern,” he said. “It’s just as much an issue with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers as it is with the county. The water flow is steady, not seasonal. It’s a lot of water – it’s not a minimal, moderate or low- quality wetland.”
Still on schedule
Despite mitigating the water issue with the tunnel, county officials are optimistic the project will be complete by September.
County Commissioner Nancy Stahoviak said she is looking forward to the future.
“We feel that, conservatively, the county will be able to move into the new building in the fall,” she said.
The county and district courtrooms, probation and the District Attorney’s Office will move into the new center.
Remodeling the Routt County Courthouse will begin shortly after the justice center is complete, which will allow the county commissioners to have a larger meeting room and will allow all the county offices to be housed in one downtown campus, including environmental health and the coroner.
The Justice Center was closed in before winter came, which has allowed crews to work primarily on the inside of the building. Exterior construction will pick up once spring arrives, he said.
The garden level of the building is nearly complete, and framing, and some drywall work has been completed on the first and second floors.
The state-of-the-art building will feature a stunning glass entrance and room for expansion.
-To reach Alexis DeLaCruz, call 871-4234
or e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
Readers around Steamboat and Routt County make the Steamboat Pilot & Today’s work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.
Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.
Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.
Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.
User Legend: Moderator Trusted User
About 30% of the children ages 5 to 11 in Routt County have received their first dose of Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine, according to data from county public health.